Karen Scheibe-Meneses
Class of 1986
- 1985 NYS Champion - Soccer
- Two-time HS All-American, 1984 & 1985
- University of Hartford: All-Region Team 1986-1989
All-Senior Team, 1989
Hartford Hall of Fame
Thomas Thatford
Class of 1977
- Two sport athlete: Football & Wrestling
- All-County Football, 1976
- Hansen Award Runner-up, 1976
- MVP – 1976 Suffolk County All-Star Game
- Played Semi-Pro Football
Kaylie Schiavetta
Class of 2004
- Two sport athlete: Basketball & Soccer
- All-Time Leading Scorer in Northport Basketball history
- Four-time All-County Basketball player
- 2004 Suffolk County Basketball Player of the Year
- 2004: NYS All-Tournament Team, 1st Team All-State, 1st Team All-Long Island
- Played at UMass & Southern Connecticut
Frank Cavagnaro
Class of 1956
- Two sport athlete: Football & Track
- Starting Guard on 1954 Suffolk County Championship Team
- Fullback & Defensive End on 1955 Championship Team
- All-Suffolk County, 1955
Thomas Henske
Class of 1990
- Three-time All-County Soccer Goalie
- HS All-American
- Career record: 41-8-8
- Led team to 3 League Championships
- Team USA U18 & U20
- University of Virginia – 3-time Division 1 National Champion Goalie
Beth Greco-Gothers
Class of 1987
- Three sport athlete: Soccer, Volleyball, Winter Track
- Soccer: HS All-American, two-time All-County player
- 1985 NYS Soccer Champion
- Volleyball: All-County, 1987
- University of Connecticut: Soccer All-American 1988 & 1989
- Led U-Conn to Final Four, 1990
- All-Freshmen Team, All-New England, All-Northeast Region teams, 1987-1990
Richard Castellano
Coach
- Girls Basketball Coach
- 613 victories (Top 5 in NYS history)
- 5 LI Championships
- 10 Suffolk County Championship Teams
- 21 League Titles
- 4-time Newsday Coach of the Year
- NYSPHSAA Hall of Fame
- Basketball Coaches Association Hall of Fame
- Also coached football, volleyball, and baseball in Northport School District
Joseph Correia
Class of 1963
- Three sport athlete: Soccer, Basketball, Baseball
- Soccer: HS All-American, All-Scholastic Honors
- Basketball: 4-year starter, All-League, MVP of Hempstead Tournament
- Penn State: 1964 Team MVP, All-American Honorable Mention
2001 Boys Lacrosse
State Champions
- Coaches: Bob Macaluso, George Searing
- Captains: Brian Amen, Kevin Cepelak, Gavin Molinelli
- Overall Record: 20 - 2
Vincent Porciello
Class of 1954
- Two sport athlete: Football & Track
- Top fullback and defensive back on 1953 squad.
- Anchor of 880-yard relay team: County best time of 1:36 in 1954 Class A Sectional Championship
- Earned football scholarship to University of Florida, but did not attend in order to serve in the US Army.
Kevin Tschirhart
Class of 2005
- One of the most accomplished track athletes in Northport High School history
- Graduated with a career 12 school, 2 Suffolk County, & 4 NY State records
- Two-time Foot Locker National Finalist
- Two-time All-American Honorable Mention
- Two-time Section XI Runner of the Year
- Four-time All-County runner
Edward Ettinger
Class of 1957
- Three sport athlete: Baseball, Football, Basketball
- Outstanding pitcher with career record of 27-0
- Led team to three Suffolk County Championships
- US Naval Academy: four-year varsity player, career record of 14-2
- Served 10 years in US Navy
Craig Dowd
Class of 2006
- Two sport athlete: Lacrosse & Football
- All-Time leading scorer in Northport Lacrosse history
- 2006 HS All-American
- Three-time All-County
- 2005 Empire State Gold Medalist
- 2006 MVP – Under Armour HS All- Star Game
- Football: All-Division
- Team USA U-19 Gold Medalist, Most Outstanding Attackman of Tournament
- Georgetown University: 2nd All-time Assists Leader
- All-ECAC & All-Big East teams