Barry Small
Class of 1972
- Three Sport Athlete: Soccer, Basketball, Baseball
- All-NYS and 2nd Team All-American
- 8th All-time goals in Suffolk County
- Four year soccer starter and two year baseball player at Colgate
- Soccer Field at Colgate is dedicated in his name
- Professional Soccer Player: NY Apollo 1976-1978
Richard Vichroski
Class of 1983
- Two Sport Athlete: Soccer and Baseball
- Member of 1980 NYS Championship Soccer Team
- Captain of 1983 County Champion Soccer and 1983 LI Champion Baseball teams
- Suffolk County Baseball Player of the Year – 1983
- Nassau Community College All-American and Hall of Fame
- All-Big East at Seton Hall
- Pitcher for 1987 Big East Champions
Regina Ronan
Class of 1987
- Four Sport Athlete: Soccer, Basketball, Track, Volleyball
- HS All-American – Soccer 1987
- 2x All-County Basketball Player
- Senior Athlete of the Year – 1987
- Soccer – Hartford: 1st Team All-New England, Captain
- Olympic Marathon Qualifier
- 2x Winner – LI Marathon
- 1st American Woman Finisher - NYC Marathon - 1995